Louis D. Brandeis, wealth and democracy: checking a common quotation (Updated)

brandeis portrait croppedWe ran across a quotation attributed to noted Supreme Court justice Louis D. Brandeis.  Curious about the context more than suspicious of its authenticity, we tried to find the source.  The quotation ended up having a number of variants.

“We may have a democracy or we may have great wealth concentrated in the hands of a few, but we cannot have both.”
“We can have a democratic society or we can have great concentrated wealth in the hands of a few. We cannot have both.”
“We can have democracy, or we can have the concentration of wealth in the hands of a few. We cannot have both.”
“We can have democracy in this country or we can have great wealth concentrated in the hands of a few, but we cannot have both.”
“We can have concentrated wealth in the hands of a few or we can have democracy. But we cannot have both.”
“We can either have democracy in this country or we can have great wealth concentrated in the hands of a few, but we cannot have both.”

A legitimate quotation can end up with a whole bunch of corrupt versions on the Web.  But in this case the trend was distressing because it took little time to run across a solid handful of variants, sometimes with more than one coming from the same person.

Our searches turned up the typical pattern of a spurious quotation:  no context, and typically no source listed.  But we found a few exceptions.

A few of the authors using variants of the quotation sourced it to others who had used it without identifying the source.  That despite the fact we were searching books and journals where going to primary sources is usually expected.

Eventually we collected a pair of leads.

We first located a reference to “Goldman, 1953, p. xi.”  Sure enough, we discovered the existence of a book, “The Words of Justice Brandeis” by Solomon Goldman, published in 1953.  But the book did not contain any recognizable variant of the quotation, and page xi was a portion of the book’s Table of Contents.

The other reference pointed to The Morrow Book of Quotations in American History.  Questia.com tempted us with a free trial which would have provided access, but we didn’t care for the attached strings.

The local library had a copy.

We found the book in the stacks and found the following version of the quotation within:

 

We can have democracy in this country or we can have great wealth concentrated in the hands of a few, but we cannot have both.

 

Finding the quotation in a reference work does much to support its authenticity.  Still, The Morrow Book of Quotations in American History is not a primary source.  It did, however, list a primary source for the quotation:  Labor, 17 Oct. 1941.

The attempt to find that source stumped two reference librarians for the better part of an hour.  We had time to puzzle over the date of the source occurring after Brandeis’ death earlier that same year.

We went next to the library staff at Brandeis University.  They couldn’t find a source more recent than Morrow, but recommended we contact Scott Campbell at the University of Louisville.  Louisville hosts an extensive collection of Brandeis’ writings, and Campbell serves as a librarian for the Louis D. Brandeis School of Law at the University of Louisville.

Campbell told us he started researching the quotation back in 2000 after receiving inquiries about it.  Presidential candidate Ralph Nader was using it in his speeches.

“The quote does not appear in anything that he wrote: not in court opinions, letters, speeches, articles, books etc.,” Campbell said.

So where did it come from?

“The only times the quote appeared in his lifetime were in editorials in the newspaper Labor, the earliest (that I can find) being in Dec. 19, 1933,” Campbell said. “Each time, the wording was a little different. On Oct. 14, 1941, shortly after Brandeis’ death, Labor ran a tribute to Brandeis in which the qu[o]te was used again, this time in the form that everyone uses now.”

Brandeis probably said it, then.  Or at least something pretty close.  But there’s no known primary source.  So how should one cite the quotation?

Campbell recommends using “attributed to Brandeis” and referencing the quotation to the book “Mr. Justice Brandeis, Great American,” published in 1941.

What was the context?

The lack of a known primary source thwarts for now the attempt to consider the context of the quotation.  Still, the search for the source brought us in contact with a number of statements from Brandeis that mean more or less the same thing.

One example comes from Brandeis’ book “Other People’s Money and How the Bankers Use It”:

 

If the bankers’ power were commensurate only with their wealth, they would have relatively little influence on American business. Vast fortunes like those of the Astors are no doubt regrettable. They are inconsistent with democracy.

 

So the quotation is consistent with Brandeis’ thinking even if he possibly never uttered it.  Attributing the quotation to Brandeis does not result, so far as we can tell, in any misrepresentation of his thinking, only a potential misrepresentation of the words he used.

Use Scott Campbell’s recommendations when citing the quotation.

 

Update June 16, 2013

Peter Scott Campbell has his account of the search for the Brandeis quotation and his hypothesis regarding its origin published in the Spring 2013 volume of the law journal The Green Bag.

We enthusiastically recommend the article to interested readers, and offer our thanks to Campbell for his indispensable help with our fact check.

 

References

Conlin, Joseph Robert. The Morrow Book of Quotations in American History. New York: W. Morrow, 1984. Print.

Brandeis, Louis D. “Our Financial Oligarchy.” Other People’s Money And How The Bankers Use It. New York: Frederick A. Stokes, 1913. 18. LOUIS D. BRANDEIS SCHOOL OF LAW. University of Louisville Louis D. Brandeis School of Law. Web. 11 Mar. 2013.

2 Comments

  1. pscamp01

    The latest issue (Spring 2013) issue of the Green Bag has my article on the genesis of the quote. It should be–fingers crossed–the final word on the subject. Scott Campbell

    Reply
    1. Bryan W. White (Post author)

      Great news, Scott! I look forward to reading it and updating this item accordingly.

      Reply

Leave a reply here or on our Facebook page

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.